View Public Posts

Below you will find reflections from policy engaged scholars, many from our Ethical Engagement Panel, about how they have managed ethically challenging moments. You can browse by author or by issue or engagement type. As you scroll through issue and engagement types, you can also find questions and answers posed through our anonymous question portal. Anyone can ask an anonymous question and our Ethical Engagement Panel responds, also anonymously. We hope these serve as resources to assist academics in reflecting on and improving their own engagement practices.

Reflections

Teaching Ethical Engagement: Media, Corruption, and Waning Accountability in Hungary

Rachel A. Epstein

Josef Korbel School of International Studies, University of Denver

The challenge:

How to help students formulate possible policy responses to undermine Fidesz’s authoritarian  grip on power in Hungary (with lessons for other authoritarian contexts).

Background and policy setting:

In offering the course to 24 graduate students at Korbel, I had two main partners: József Péter Martin, executive director of Transparency International, Hungary, and Dóra Piroska, professor at Central European

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Addressing Uncomfortable Recommendations: Perpetrators and Person-First Language

Dr. Hollie Nyseth Nzitatira

Associate Professor of Sociology

Ohio State

Type of engagement

This reflection is relevant to people engaging with government officials, policymakers, practitioners, educators, and those who experienced atrocities.

The Challenge
  • How to advocate for policy recommendations that, at face value, cause discomfort.
Background

Dr. Nyseth Nzitatira (aka Hollie Nyseth Brehm) obtained her Ph.D. in Sociology at the University of Minnesota in 2014. She is an

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Defining “Enduring Strategic Defeat”: Ethical Dilemmas or Security Dilemmas?

Jesse Driscoll

Introductory Note: Jesse Driscoll is an associate professor of political science at the University of California San Diego (UCSD). He is an area specialist in Central Asia, the Causcasus, and the Russian-speaking world. In 2022, he took a year's leave from UCSD to serve in the Plans division of the Joint Staff (J5, Europe/NATO/Russia Division). The following narrative includes his

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

The U.S. Role In and Foreign Policy Debate On Afghanistan

Dipali Mukhopadhyay

The challenges:

  • Present recommendations on the U.S. role in Afghanistan along with empirically informed enumeration of various potential decisions and outcomes
  • Bring a different range of voices and perspectives into the U.S. foreign policy debate on Afghanistan
  • Grapple with what to do with knowledge production that is unused in policy creation

The background and policy setting:

Dipali Mukhopadhyay

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Navigating Ethical Complexity and Contracting in Multi-Stakeholder Projects

Charli Carpenter

The challenges:

  • Balancing the desire to collaborate with / provide analytical support to a government agency on a matter of crucial national and human security importance, with the need to maintain institutional and analytical autonomy in our own academic-practitioner interactions.
  • Managing expectations by practitioners / policymakers about what type of analysis could be reasonably and ethically produced under time

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

“Just War” Debates and Evolving Uses of Force

Daniel Brunstetter

The challenges:

  • Moving beyond academic critique and arm’s length critiques of defense policy from a “just war” perspective to discussions within military circles based on a more interdisciplinary perspective
  • Engaging with future peace and security policymakers to update the “moral vocabulary” around the use of force to take into account the new dilemmas of force short of war, such

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Ethical Concerns on a Research Project

Sarah Parkinson

The challenges:

  • How to decide when to remove oneself from a research project due to ethical concerns
  • How to informally report on policy processes and retain policy relevance even while disengaging from a specific project

The background and policy setting:

Parkinson earned her Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of Chicago in 2013. She researches organizational behavior

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

AI and Machine Learning in the U.S. Military Context

John R. Emery

The challenges:

  • Determining in which stages of development or deployment of technology to engage with machine learning, using a just war logic
  • Choosing to closely engage with a military project as a critical scholar, given that the use of the project may result in the loss of human life

The background and policy setting:

John R. Emery is

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Requests for Revisions That Go Against One’s Findings

Elisabeth King

The Challenge:

Responding to requests for substantive revisions to consultancy work that go against one’s findings, analysis, or professional opinion

The Background and Policy Setting:

King is a political scientist committed to conducting policy-relevant research related to war, peace, development, and education. Over the past 15 years, alongside her university-based work, she has partnered with a number of governments, non-governmental

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement: ,

Engaging with Business to Encourage Responsible Behavior

Virginia Haufler

The challenges:

  • How to collaborate with business representatives in ways that generate fruitful conversations while maintaining your own integrity and reputation
  • How to recommend partnerships with business to solve global problems without damaging the partners' reputation and legitimacy or providing business with a shield against legitimate criticism

Background:

Virginia Haufler is a scholar whose research explores the governance

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Engaging with Authoritarian Regimes in Academic Spaces

Miles Kahler

The challenge:

  • Navigating whether and how to engage with authoritarian regimes in academic spaces
  • Lending support to voices situated in authoritarian regimes, without jeopardizing their work and safety

The background and policy setting:

Miles Kahler is a distinguished professor at American University in the fields of international politics and international political economy and Senior Fellow for global governance

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Engaging With Policymakers

Jacqueline Best

The challenges:

  • Identifying and understanding the limits and failures of policy expertise, as well as the role and nature of policy ignorance when engaging with policymakers, while acknowledging that policymakers who work in the field of economics are often under a great deal of pressure to get things right
  • Approaching issues as a political economist and a social theorist,

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Engaging with identity politics during times of heightened polarization

Nadia Brown

The challenges:

  • How to show the value of diversity and intersectionality for policymaking in an era of heightened polarization.
  • How to effectively contribute to the policy arena as a black feminist when your expertise is in question from the gate given who you are.
  • How to push against situations where your identity brings diversity, but you are expected

Read More »

Issue Areas: , , Type of Engagement:

Navigating Positionality on Racial Profiling by Police

The challenges:

  • Navigating positionality in academic work and community engagement on racial profiling by police
  • Improving the ethical issues surrounding expert witnesses, public speaking, and training

The background and policy setting:

This reflection was completed by a professor who studies the economics of stratification, considering such topics as equitable growth, gender, and macroeconomic tools. Their primary research focus

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Ethics of Engagement and Sources of Funding

Tanisha M. Fazal

The challenges:

  • How to fund policy relevant research without compromising ethics.
  • The complexities of managing government funding.
  • The dilemmas of private foundation funding.
  • The positionality of funding dilemmas.

The background and policy setting:

All scholars need funding for research. Sometimes we need to pay for field research, sometimes for surveys. Sometimes – indeed, often – what we most

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Matrix: writing for policy audiences, economic/tech space

Shareen Hertel

The challenge:

  • Providing policy advice on corporate engagement to one’s university from a human rights perspective, while being far removed from corporate decision-making.
  • Providing advice to the university as a professor but in a context that operates according to different norms from her teaching and research responsibilities.

The background and policy setting:

Hertel became an academic after over

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement:

Engaging to Reform U.S. Democracy Promotion

Catherine Herrold

Background and Policy Setting

Catherine Herrold studies how local civic actors—including nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), grassroots groups, and philanthropic foundations—promote economic development and democratic political reform. Her first book project examined how leaders of Egyptian NGOs and foundations understood the concept of “democracy” and promoted it in the wake of the 2011 Arab Spring uprisings. In 2020, Herrold published the

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Engaging on the Creation of Cybersecurity Norms

Martha Finnemore

The challenge: How to advise on complex phenomena (creating cybersecurity norms) when the narrative surrounding them is oversimplified.

  • In particular, it is difficult to explain to policymakers the intersubjectivity of norms and their sociological basis in a way that is immediately policy relevant.
  • The “problem” in question often involves many dimensions not related to norms at all.
  • The

Read More »

Issue Areas: , Type of Engagement: ,

Engaging to Encourage a Global NATO

James Goldgeier

The challenges:
  • How to present novel, controversial ideas without damaging one’s credibility in the policy circles in which one travels
  • How to present views that may be considered extreme, with the goal of reframing the policy space on a particular issue
The background and policy setting:

James Goldgeier has worked for many years on NATO. In the

Read More »

Issue Areas: Type of Engagement:

Questions

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Compensation for meetings/presentations

Engagement Experiences:

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Political Economy Analysis with an International Organization

Issue Areas: Engagement Experiences:

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Proper disclosure vs. taking credit for behind-the-scenes policy advice

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Misuse of research by violent actors

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Is there an ethical issue involved in looking at the pandemic as a research opportunity?

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Engagement with Trump Administration

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

How much do I need to know to engage media

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Consulting fees/rates

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

How to be relevant when researching both sides of a conflict

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Engaging with media from authoritarian regimes

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Changing assessments based on sponsor sensitivities?

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Help? I’m trapped in a broom closet!

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Can I go back to the editors of a website and defend a point?

View Full Question & Answers

Date submitted:

Question Summary:

Conflict of interest?

View Full Question & Answers

Ethics of Engagement